Panel discussion

Which questions carry a panel discussion?

Good panel questions are short, concrete and addressed to a named person. This page shows example questions for the opening, the escalation, the follow-up and the closing, plus the rules for building your own.

Good panel questions are short, concrete and addressed to a named person. This page shows example questions for the opening, the escalation, the follow-up and the closing, plus the rules for building your own.

Four rules for good panel questions

First: one question per sentence. Give guests a double question and they will always answer the more comfortable half. Second: address a person by name, never "the panel", or nobody answers and the loudest voice fills the gap. Third: concrete beats abstract. Asking about a decision, a price tag or a failed attempt yields more than any question of principle. Fourth: no lecture before the question. Forty seconds of context steal the stage from the guest and the tension from the room.

Example questions for the opening

The opening brings every person into play early, ideally through experience rather than opinion. Examples: "Ms Berger, your company has been through this transition. What did it really cost?" or "Mr Yilmaz, why did your first attempt fail?" or "You advise both sides: who is hesitating more right now, and why?" Questions like these force nobody into a defensive crouch, yet they immediately produce material the others can react to.

Example questions for escalation and follow-up

In the middle the conversation needs friction. The escalation confronts one position with another: "Ms Berger says it will not work without subsidies. You disagree: where is she wrong?" or "What result would make you change your position?" or "What does your industry prefer not to mention in this debate?" Just as important is the follow-up when an answer stays vague: "What do you base that on?", "What does that mean in practice for a company of 200 people?", "That was the diagnosis, what is your therapy?" It is the second question that turns talking points into a conversation.

Involving the audience and closing

Before the audience round, build a bridge: "Before the room takes over: what would you ask each other?" From the audience, the moderator condenses statements into questions instead of letting co-lectures run. At the end, a good question demands commitment: "What has to be different in twelve months for this evening to have been worth it?" or "Which sentence from today will you take with you?" At her own panels, Jasmin Wölke works with a question catalogue as a reserve: she only asks what the conversation needs. The full preparation process is described in preparing a panel discussion, what an external moderator takes over is on panel discussion moderation, and the briefing checklist collects the key facts for your briefing.

Request a date

Is your date still available?

Send the date, the venue and the type of event. You will get an answer within one working day.

Frequently asked questions

How long may a panel question be?
One sentence, ideally under 15 words. Anything longer is a lecture with a question mark. If context is needed, it belongs in a short separate sentence before the question, not inside it.
Who gets the first question?
Not automatically the most senior person. Better the one with the most tangible experience of the topic, because their answer gives the others something to react to. The remaining guests should still come into play within the first minutes.
May the moderator wrap their own opinions into questions?
Sharpening yes, taking sides no. A good question confronts a guest with another guest's claim or with a fact, not with the moderator's view. The role stays neutral while the edge stays in the conversation.
What if nobody wants to answer a question?
Make it more concrete and name a person: instead of "How do you see this?" try "Ms Berger, would you sign off on that?" If that fails too, briefly acknowledge the silence and move on. Nothing drags like a question repeated three times.
How many audience questions fit into a 45-minute panel?
Three to four real questions with answers are realistic. More only works with tight microphone management or digitally collected questions from which the moderator picks and bundles the best.

Related pages

All cities and formatsAll servicesReferencesAbout Jasmin Wölke